Subscribe To The Cybersecurity Insider Newsletter
Understanding the Value of Darknet Markets
The phenomenon of darknet markets has gained significant attention in recent years, primarily for their hidden nature and the wide array of products they offer. Many people are curious about how much value is on the darknet markets, considering their illicit nature and the complexities surrounding them.
Weapons – Firearms, explosives, and other weapons are also available on darknet markets. Vendors offer a range of weapons, from handguns to assault rifles, and even hand grenades and rocket launchers. Your personal data will always be vulnerable, with dark web forums continuing to provide hacking requirements to attackers. It’s high time organizations and users realize the value of their personal data and how it can cause damage if it falls into wrong hands.
The Scope of Darknet Markets
The most notable example of this is drainware – smart contracts that, upon interaction, grant the attacker permission to move funds from the victim’s wallet. Two of the largest were Forsage and the Trade Coin Club, while the Bitconnect founder was indicted by the US Department of Justice (DOJ) following charges from the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) in 2021. In April 2023, the US, Japan and South Korea accused Pyongyang of funding its WMD programme using stolen cryptocurrency.
Darknet markets function as online platforms where goods and services are exchanged, often circumventing traditional legal frameworks. These markets are notorious for offering:
The attacker then demands a ransom, usually in cryptocurrency, in exchange for the decryption key. Ransomware has become a significant threat to individuals, businesses, and even governments, with high-profile attacks making headlines. In May 2023 a former employee of a public New York-based technology company was sentenced to six years in prison for stealing company files and demanding nearly USD 2 million for their return.
- The gambling process involves customers paying money into a casino or bookmakers’ and later cashing out any winnings along with the remaining funds and an official receipt.
- This method was seen as less risky for buyers and sellers fearful of the heavy prison sentences handed out in Russia for drug crimes.
- Millions of regular internet users access private databases such as email inboxes and credit card accounts daily.
- Even developing nations are not immune to these threats- Nations like India are investing heavily in transforming its digital architecture to provide public services electronically and encourage citizens to use the internet and the online services being provided.
- Cryptocurrency-based gambling platforms make it difficult to trace funds through the service.
Conti shut down its operations and rebranded into at least three smaller groups – Black Basta, Karakurt, and BlackByte. Pig butchering scams rely on psychological manipulation and social engineering to wipe out victims’ life savings on the promise of making large returns on their investments. Such scams often include the widespread use of Tether by scammers, significant interconnectivity between individual pig butchering scams, and links to transnational organized criminal groups. Because scams in general are significantly under-reported by victims, it is difficult to quantify the scale of pig butchering globally. TRM Labs identified about USD 9.04 billion being sent to various types of fraud schemes in 2022, with the large majority going to apparent Ponzi and/or pyramid schemes.
- Illegal drugs – A major category that dominates transactions.
- Stolen data – Including credit card numbers and personal identification.
- Hacking services – Such as DDoS attacks or personal information retrieval.
- Counterfeit goods – From luxury items to counterfeit documents.
What makes this more important is the fact that drug markets on the dark web only emerged a decade or so ago. If we exclude Hydra, we see that darknet market revenue stayed roughly flat from 2019 to 2020. Hydra is unique in that it only serves Russian-speaking countries, and is by far the largest darknet market in the world, accounting for over 75% of darknet market revenue worldwide in 2020. Darknet markets set a new revenue record in 2020, bringing in a total of $1.7 billion worth of cryptocurrency—most of which was in Bitcoin (BTC). The most common ways to introduce malware are through fake online casinos, social networks, fake websites, etc. For every 1,000 installations, hackers can steal tens of thousands of dollars.
Dark fox is the only darknet market that currently has a credit card auto shop. Hydra, which had a long-standing review system and significant entry barriers for potential sellers, provided a useful platform for vendors, including crypto launderers, to prove that they were trustworthy. The trust Hydra commanded among users is obvious from how Kraken Market, which claims to be a project of former Hydra administrators, even designed its logo to make it similar to Hydra’s. In fact, there’s no evidence that Hydra and Kraken were developed by the same team. Nonetheless, threat actors adapted, with many choosing to move to the “RuTor” forum for communications and to decentralized platforms such as Telegram-based shops for drug advertisements, as well as offline sales.
Fill out the form to speak with our team about investigative professional services. In addition to the critically important efforts of the German Federal Criminal Police, significant assistance was provided by the Justice Department’s Office of International Affairs and the U.S. Assistance was also provided by the Justice Department’s National Cryptocurrency Enforcement Team.
But as detailed in a groundbreaking report by TrustedSite on the market for stolen digital information, credit and debit cards are not necessarily the usual target of cybercriminals and fraudsters today. Increasingly the targets are the password-protected online payment service accounts. Unlike with credit cards where the cost per card is determined by the different factors the buyer selects, the cost of this stolen data is related largely to the balances in the online accounts. They can be had for as little as $100 for access to accounts with $2,000 or less. Or they can cost upwards of $1,000 for access to accounts with $15,000 or more. It is not a surprise to see ‘credit cards’ being sold in the darknet markets as they are further used to commit fraud and are also used by cybercriminals to finance their requirements and make profit.
Estimating Value on Darknet Markets
Determining the total monetary value present on darknet markets is challenging due to their secretive nature. However, several studies and expert estimates provide insights into what this value might look like:
- Recent estimates suggest that darknet markets facilitate transactions exceeding $800 million annually.
- The value can fluctuate significantly based on various factors, including law enforcement activity, market closures, and technological advancements.
- In addition to financial transactions, the value of information shared within these markets can reach into the billions if considering the economic impact of data breaches and identity theft.
Major Players in the Darknet Ecosystem
Some notable markets that have contributed significantly to this valuation include:
- Silk Road – Pioneered the concept and amassed millions in total sales before its closure.
- AlphaBay – Known for a vast array of illegal goods, similar in scale to Silk Road.
- Hansa Market – Operated for years, merely to be taken down as part of undercover operations by law enforcement.
Factors Influencing the Value of Darknet Markets
Several factors influence the overall value present in the darknet:
- Law Enforcement Actions – Frequent takedowns of major markets can create volatility in prices and availability.
- User Trust – The reputation of a market plays a significant role in how much value it can gather.
- Cryptocurrency Prices – Many transactions on darknet markets are conducted using cryptocurrencies, thus their valuation can directly affect the market.
FAQs about Darknet Market Value
Q: Why is it difficult to measure the value on darknet markets?
A: The anonymous nature of these markets, coupled with illegal activities, makes reliable tracking and valuation challenging.
Q: What role do cryptocurrencies play in the valuation of darknet markets?
A: Cryptocurrencies facilitate anonymous transactions, making them the preferred currency for trades on these platforms, thus impacting their overall value.
Q: Are darknet markets growing or declining in value?
A: While certain markets continue to emerge, the value fluctuates in response to regulatory pressures and market dynamics.
In conclusion, the value on darknet markets represents a complex intertwining of economics and legality. As this ecosystem evolves, so too does our understanding of its scale and implications.
